Ontario’s top court nixes Ford’s third-party election ad spending rules


Published March 6, 2023 at 3:51 pm

doug ford

Ontario’s top court has struck down third-party election advertising rules introduced by Premier Doug Ford’s government as unconstitutional.

Before 2021, third parties were allowed to spend up to $600,000 on advertising in the six months before an election call, but that year the government stretched the pre-election restricted spending period to one year while not increasing the amount.

The Ontario PC Party government argued the extended restriction was necessary to protect elections from outside influence, but critics said it amounted to the government trying to silence criticism ahead of the 2022 provincial election.

The law was found unconstitutional on free speech grounds, so the government reintroduced the provisions using the notwithstanding clause, a section of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms that guards against constitutional challenges.

A coalition of third parties, including teachers’ unions, challenged that reintroduced law, and Ontario’s Court of Appeal has now sided with them.

The court writes in its ruling that in this case, the third parties argued the law violated a different section of the Charter  – one not subject to the notwithstanding clause – on a voter’s right to meaningful participation in the electoral process.

The judges agreed, in a split decision, and gave the government one year to create new, Charter-compliant, legislation.

The PC Party has two MPPs in the Hamilton area — Tourism, Culture and Sport Minister Neil Lumsden (Hamilton East—Stoney Creek) and backbencher Donna Skelly (Flamborough—Glanbrook). The Ontario NDP also have two MPPs, Sandy Shaw (Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas) and Monique Taylor (Hamilton Mountain). A byelection on March 16 will decide who fills the Hamilton Centre seat that Mayor Andrea Horwath vacated last summer when she moved to municipal politics after resigning as MPP and the ONDP leader.

— The Canadian Press

insauga's Editorial Standards and Policies advertising